Trump Bid For Immunity Rejected Leaving Supreme Court As Last Option

 January 9, 2024

Former President Donald Trump's quest for immunity was quashed in a significant legal setback.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit has denied Donald Trump's request for presidential immunity in a defamation lawsuit filed by E. Jean Carroll.

This recent legal development is pivotal in the ongoing battle between Trump and Carroll. The brief, single-page decision consisted of just two sentences, yet it effectively narrowed Trump's legal options. With the avenue to the U.S. Supreme Court as his only remaining path, the tension surrounding the case intensifies.

A Legal Blow to Trump's Defense

The refusal to grant immunity to Trump has cast a new light on presidential accountability. The decision has set the stage for the next act in this legal drama: a second defamation trial. This trial, commencing on January 16th, will concentrate on the financial recompense owed by Trump for Carroll's defamation claim.

The jury's previous verdict, which found Trump guilty of defamation and sexual abuse but not of rape, awarded Carroll over $5 million. The upcoming trial will not revisit these findings but will focus solely on the damages due. The stakes are high, as the monetary compensation could be substantial.

This development comes as a blow to Trump, who has consistently maintained his innocence. The denial of immunity by the 2nd Circuit is a reminder that even those who have held the highest office are not beyond the reach of the judiciary.

The Implications for Presidential Privilege

The legal implications of this decision are far-reaching. The concept of presidential immunity has been debated throughout history, and this rejection adds a new layer to that discourse. It underscores the notion that the legal system views the President as subject to the same laws as the general citizenry.

Carroll's legal team is preparing for the upcoming trial with renewed vigor. The denial of Trump's appeal for immunity has likely bolstered their resolve. They are expected to argue for significant damages to compensate for the harm Carroll has endured.

As Trump turns to the Supreme Court, the gravity of the situation is palpable. The highest court in the land may be asked to weigh in on this landmark case. The decision of whether to hear Trump's appeal could have implications not only for this case but for the understanding of presidential immunity in the years to come.


The legal saga between former President Donald Trump and E. Jean Carroll continues with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit rejecting Trump's bid for presidential immunity. This leaves the Supreme Court as his last resort for appeal. The upcoming defamation trial, set to begin on January 16th, will focus on damages owed by Trump.

The implications of this case extend beyond the individuals involved, touching on the accountability of the presidency and the legal boundaries of defamation. The nation watches with bated breath as this story unfolds, with the potential to shape legal precedent and the public's understanding of justice.

About Aileen Barro

With years of experience at the forefront of political commentary, Robert Cunningham brings a blend of sharp wit and deep insight to his analysis of American principles at the Capitalism Institute.

Top Articles



Receive information on new articles posted, important topics and tips.
Join Now
We won't send you spam. 
Unsubscribe at any time.

Recent Articles

Recent Analysis

Copyright © 2024 -
A Project of Connell Media.