New Jersey mayor shifts support to Republican Ciattarelli in governor’s race

 September 30, 2025, NEWS

A New Jersey Democratic mayor has made a surprising move by endorsing a Republican in the state’s heated gubernatorial contest. This decision is sending ripples through the political landscape of the Garden State.

According to Fox News, Dover Mayor James P. Dodd has thrown his support behind Jack Ciattarelli, a Republican endorsed by former President Donald Trump, over Democratic Rep. Mikie Sherrill. Dodd’s choice highlights deep frustrations with current state policies and a hunger for tangible change.

This race, already a tight one, sees Ciattarelli challenging Sherrill after a narrow loss to term-limited Gov. Phil Murphy in 2021. Dodd’s public backing of Ciattarelli, rooted in concerns over rising taxes and ineffective leadership, adds a new layer of intensity to the campaign.

Concerns Over Sanctuary Policies Take Center Stage

Dodd pointed to immigration policy as a key reason for his shift, particularly New Jersey’s status as a sanctuary state. He praised Ciattarelli’s pledge to end such policies on day one, arguing that law enforcement needs freedom to operate without restrictive directives.

“On day one, Jack made a commitment to end sanctuary cities,” Dodd said on Fox & Friends First. That kind of clarity is refreshing when so many politicians dodge the hard questions with vague promises.

Sherrill, meanwhile, avoided a direct stance on the Immigrant Trust Directive during a recent debate, a policy limiting police cooperation with federal immigration authorities. Her hesitation to commit speaks volumes, suggesting a reluctance to confront the real-world consequences of such rules in communities like Dover.

Community Frustrations Fuel Political Shift

In Dover, a predominantly Hispanic town about 40 miles west of Manhattan, Dodd noted a growing disillusionment with the Democratic status quo. He sees a trend of residents, tired of a failing system, moving toward Republican candidates.

“We’re seeing a lot of Hispanics go from Democrat to Republican because they’re tired of the system that doesn’t work any longer,” Dodd explained. This shift isn’t just anecdotal; it reflects a broader demand for leaders who prioritize results over party loyalty.

Dodd himself has faced pushback from fellow Democrats for his endorsement, yet he stands firm in prioritizing what he believes is best for his community. His focus on practical governance over partisan allegiance could resonate with others feeling similarly fed up.

Criticism of Sherrill’s Lack of Solutions

Having supported Sherrill in the past, Dodd now finds her campaign lacking in concrete answers to pressing issues like skyrocketing retirement costs and relentless tax hikes. “We don’t hear real solutions from Mikie,” he stated, cutting to the heart of voter frustration.

State spending, another sore point, continues to balloon without clear justification, according to Dodd. When leaders fail to address these bread-and-butter concerns, they risk losing even their staunchest allies.

Ciattarelli, by contrast, has made multiple visits to Dover, laying out a vision that Dodd finds actionable. That kind of direct engagement shows a willingness to listen, something sorely missing in today’s political theater.

A Potential Party Switch Looms Large

While still a registered Democrat, Dodd hasn’t ruled out a full switch to the Republican side. “If I do decide to flip to Republican, a lot of council members will go with me,” he hinted, signaling a potential wave of defections.

This isn’t just one mayor’s rebellion; it’s a warning to party leaders that blind loyalty won’t cut it when constituents are struggling. If Dodd’s prediction holds, New Jersey’s political map could see a significant redraw.

For now, his endorsement of Ciattarelli stands as a bold call for change, challenging the entrenched policies that have left many feeling unheard. Whether this move inspires a broader realignment or remains a lone stand, it underscores a simple truth: people want leaders who deliver, not just debate.

About Robert Cunningham

Robert is a conservative commentator focused on American politics and current events. Coverage ranges from elections and public policy to media narratives and geopolitical conflict. The goal is clarity over consensus.
Copyright © 2026 - CapitalismInstitute.org
A Project of Connell Media.
magnifier