Idaho Supreme Court Denied Appeal Request From Suspected Killer

 March 14, 2024

A harrowing act of violence disrupted the tranquility of a university community.

According to Daily Wire, the Idaho Supreme Court has rebuffed an attempt to dismiss the charges against a man implicated in the murder of four University of Idaho students in 2022 while acquiescing to seal the appeal documents.

Attorneys for the 29-year-old suspect challenged a lower court's ruling that declined to drop the case against him, according to sources including KTVB. Their appeal, lodged on February 8, was denied this past Tuesday, marking a significant development in a case that has lingered heavily over the University of Idaho and its surrounding community.

Legal Battles and Sealed Documents

The Supreme Court has acceded to the defendant's plea to conceal the documents related to the appeal. The defense had raised several objections, arguing that prejudicial grand jury processes and prosecutorial misconduct marred the integrity of the initial proceedings. They contended that the grand jury was misinformed, reliant on evidence that should be deemed inadmissible, and led astray by insufficient proof.

The accused faces serious charges, including four counts of murder and one count of burglary, related to the tragic demise of Ethan Chapin, Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle, and Madison Mogen. A web of evidence has slowly emerged, piecing together a timeframe and a sequence of events that have led investigators to believe they have their suspect.

The defense, in their essays to the court, voiced skepticism toward the investigation’s handling of DNA evidence:

The State’s argument asks this Court and [the suspect] to assume – is that the DNA on the sheath was placed there by [the suspect], and not someone else during an investigation that spans hundreds of members of law enforcement and at least one lab the State refuses to name.

Evidence in the Spotlight

An intricate montage of video surveillance was contributed to the arrest, capturing a white Hyundai Elantra connected to the suspect in the vicinity during the crucial window between 4:00 a.m. and 4:25 a.m. on November 13, 2022. This vehicle, absent a front license plate, became a feature of the investigation, illustrating the suspect's purported movements before and after the crime.

Further analysis unveiled the suspect's tactical alteration to his vehicle's registration, transitioning to Washington plates merely five days after the murders. This maneuver raised suspicions and subsequently helped police link the vehicle to him. Two weeks after the crime, this connection became clearer as law enforcement identified his vehicle, which was registered at WSU.

Amidst swirling allegations, the suspect's defense has proposed the provocative theory that DNA evidence discovered at the crime scene may have been strategically planted, casting a shadow of doubt over the investigative process and suggesting a potential miscarriage of justice.

The Path Forward in a Complex Case

Yet, despite the layers of legal contestations and the searing grief of a community in mourning, a trial date remains undetermined. The confluence of appeals, procedural debates, and forensic scrutinies underscores the intricate legal journey ahead.

As the case against the accused murderer of four University of Idaho students persists without resolution, the Idaho Supreme Court's decision to deny the appeal while sealing its documents represents a critical juncture.


The Idaho Supreme Court’s secrecy around an appeal in the brutal murder of four University of Idaho students has fueled intense speculation, as attorneys for the accused suspect tried unsuccessfully to have the charges dismissed. While the precise grounds of the appeal remain obscured at the defendant’s request, his lawyers have questioned the DNA evidence tying their client to the crime scene and implied investigative missteps may have contaminated findings.

As prosecutors build their case amid vigorously contested evidence, the concealed particulars of the appeal cast an air of intrigue over the ongoing legal battle, keeping crucial details of Idaho’s most infamous crime shrouded in mystery. While legally justified, The court’s confidentiality adds another complex layer to an already enigmatic tragedy that shocked a university and community. Until further facts emerge, ambiguity and conjecture seem destined to linger in the proceedings’ background.

About Victor Winston

Victor is a freelance writer and researcher who focuses on national politics, geopolitics, and economics.

Top Articles



Receive information on new articles posted, important topics and tips.
Join Now
We won't send you spam. 
Unsubscribe at any time.

Recent Articles

Recent Analysis

Copyright © 2024 -
A Project of Connell Media.