GOP splits over Trump's $5 billion spending cut decision

 September 3, 2025, NEWS

President Donald Trump’s latest move to slash $5 billion in congressionally approved spending has ignited a firestorm among his own party, raising alarms about legality and the specter of a government shutdown.

According to NBC News, Trump’s unilateral decision, dubbed a “pocket rescission,” bypasses Congress in a way that some Republican senators are calling a direct challenge to their authority. This isn’t just a policy disagreement; it’s a constitutional clash that could grind government operations to a halt.

Key figures like Senate Appropriations Committee Chair Susan Collins of Maine didn’t mince words, labeling the action “a clear violation of the law.” Her disappointment signals a deeper unease among centrists and conservatives alike who see this as an end-run around the legislative process they’re sworn to uphold.

Growing Discontent Among GOP Senators

Sen. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, another senior appropriator, echoed Collins’ concerns, branding the move “unlawful” and a threat to bipartisan work. She noted a “solid number” of her colleagues share this worry, hinting at a brewing rebellion within GOP ranks.

Sen. Mike Rounds of South Dakota added that the rescission hands Democrats a reason to stonewall, jeopardizing the bipartisan approach to appropriations. His frustration reveals a pragmatic fear: this could derail any chance of passing a funding bill.

Even Sen. Kevin Cramer of North Dakota, while acknowledging the power of the presidency, admitted to unease over separation of powers. He’s not ruling out joining a potential congressional lawsuit, a striking sign of how far some Republicans might go to defend their turf.

Defenders of Trump’s Fiscal Gambit

Not all in the GOP are sounding the alarm, as Sen. John Kennedy of Louisiana stands firmly with the administration. With a national debt of $37 trillion, he argues that critics obsessing over process are dodging the real issue: spending must be reined in.

Kennedy dismissed hypothetical fears of a future Democratic president abusing this power, focusing instead on the present crisis. His stance reflects a slice of the party willing to back Trump’s aggressive fiscal tactics, even at the cost of congressional norms.

This split within the Republican camp shows a tension between principle and pragmatism, with some prioritizing debt reduction over procedural purity. It’s a gamble that could either rally the base or fracture party unity at a critical juncture.

Democrats Seize the Opportunity

Across the aisle, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer of New York accused Trump of waging “an all-out war” on Congress’s constitutional authority. His sharp rhetoric frames this as a defining moment for Republicans to choose between loyalty to Trump or the legislative branch.

Sen. Peter Welch of Vermont went further, suggesting Trump’s move is a deliberate signal he wants a shutdown, not just a spending cut. This accusation paints the president’s strategy as less about fiscal responsibility and more about political brinkmanship.

Schumer’s alignment with House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries signals a united front among Democrats, ready to hold the line against what they see as executive overreach. Their stance could harden negotiations, pushing the government closer to a standstill.

Political Stakes and Uncertain Outcomes

The standoff carries political weight beyond policy, especially for figures like Collins, whose Maine seat leans liberal and whose future plans remain unclear. Picking a fight with her, as Cramer wryly noted, is rarely a winning strategy given her clout and preparation.

Cramer’s quip about the “political capital” spent on such battles hints at a broader concern: alienating key moderates could cost more than just a funding bill. It’s a reminder that internal GOP rifts might play into Democratic hands if tensions boil over.

As the Senate scrambles for next steps this week, the risk of a shutdown looms larger than ever, with both sides digging in. Trump’s bold stroke may aim to cut fat, but it’s slicing into party cohesion and congressional power, leaving a messy path ahead.

About Craig Barlow

Craig is a conservative observer of American political life. Their writing covers elections, governance, cultural conflict, and foreign affairs. The focus is on how decisions made in Washington and beyond shape the country in real terms.
Copyright © 2026 - CapitalismInstitute.org
A Project of Connell Media.
magnifier