Ex-Trooper Giancarlo DiGenova Escapes Jail In Plea Deal For Evidence Theft

 April 8, 2024

Former Vermont state trooper Giancarlo DiGenova has bypassed prison by striking a plea deal over the theft of $40,000 in evidence, including a high-value Rolex watch.

DiGenova, once a respected law enforcer, resigned from his post in February 2023 amid an investigation that unveiled his involvement in the theft of various high-priced items from a police storage room.

According to the Daily Mail, these items included Rolex and diamond jewelry, designer accessories, and medication. His plea agreement led to a sentence of community service, fines, probation, and the possibility of expunging the larceny charges from his record if he meets certain conditions.

A Trooper's Fall From Grace

Giancarlo DiGenova's career came to a screeching halt in February 2023 when he resigned amidst an investigation into his actions. It was revealed that items, including a high-value Rolex watch, diamond jewelry, and even ADHD medication, had been stolen from a storage room at the Williston barracks, actions unbefitting an officer of the law.

In a move that has since sparked debate, DiGenova was able to avoid incarceration through a plea agreement. Under this agreement's terms, he must complete community service, pay fines, and engage in a restorative justice program. While some view this as a fair compromise, others question whether it adequately addresses the offenses' severity.

Wearing the uniform of the Vermont State Police, DiGenova had once represented law and order, a stark contrast to the figure who walked into a jewelry store to get a stolen Rolex appraised. This betrayal underscores a troubling breach of ethics and duty, highlighting the need for vigilance and accountability within our law enforcement agencies.

A Second Chance or a Missed Opportunity?

DiGenova's guilty plea to charges ranging from felony grand theft to neglect of duty paints a complex picture of a man who once pledged to serve and protect. The leniency of his sentence, including probation and the potential to have larceny charges removed from his record, raises questions about the consequences those in positions of power face when they falter.

The judge's referral to the plea agreement as a "second chance" for DiGenova has been met with mixed reactions. For some, it represents a belief in redemption and the capacity for individuals to learn from their mistakes. For others, it's a troubling precedent that may not sufficiently deter future misconduct.

Chittenden County State’s Attorney Sarah George described the plea agreement as "fair," emphasizing the importance of the misdemeanors in ensuring DiGenova can no longer serve as a police officer. This statement, however, does little to quell the concerns of those who feel justice has been unduly lenient, especially considering the magnitude of the breach of trust.

Additional Charges and Pending Cases

Further complicating DiGenova's story are the pending charges against him in Washington County related to similar thefts at the Berlin State Police barracks. These allegations suggest a pattern of behavior that extends beyond a single instance of poor judgment, indicating a more deep-seated issue within the individual.

The discovery of additional stolen items, including a diamond dust pendant and a gold necklace, being sold on eBay has added another layer to the case. This behavior highlights the extent of DiGenova's actions and their impact on the victims from whom these items were stolen.

As DiGenova faces these additional charges, which were not covered by the plea agreement, the community is left to ponder the justice system's effectiveness in addressing such breaches of trust. The case serves as a reminder of the vulnerabilities within our institutions and the ongoing need for reforms to ensure accountability and integrity.


Giancarlo DiGenova's case is a poignant reminder of the fragility of trust and the importance of accountability within law enforcement. His plea agreement, while offering him a path toward redemption, raises significant questions about the adequacy of our justice system in dealing with breaches of public trust. The community's reaction to this case reflects broader concerns over integrity within the police force and the need for systemic changes to prevent future incidents. As DiGenova moves forward, the lasting impact of his actions on the Vermont State Police and the community it serves will not be easily forgotten. This case underscores the critical need for transparency, accountability, and stringent ethical standards within law enforcement.

About Robert Cunningham

With years of experience at the forefront of political commentary, Robert Cunningham brings a blend of sharp wit and deep insight to his analysis of American principles at the Capitalism Institute.

Top Articles



Receive information on new articles posted, important topics and tips.
Join Now
We won't send you spam. 
Unsubscribe at any time.

Recent Articles

Recent Analysis

Copyright © 2024 - CapitalismInstitute.org
A Project of Connell Media.