Defies Supreme Court Ruling And Promises More Student Loan Handouts

 March 25, 2024

Fox News reported that President Joe Biden is pushing the envelope further on student loan forgiveness in bold defiance of fiscal caution and judicial skepticism.

This endeavor comes despite the towering national debt and a clear rebuff from the U.S. Supreme Court, signaling a contentious battle ahead.

The stage is set for a policy clash that touches the lives of millions of Americans, intertwining financial dreams with political ambition.

A Stubborn Pursuit Amid Soaring Debts

The national debt, now eclipsing $34.5 trillion, looms large over Biden's ambitious plan. It's a figure so immense that it's difficult for the average American to fathom, yet it underscores the gravity of the decision to forgive billions in student loans. This debt forgiveness plan is not just about alleviating the financial burden on students; it's a statement about the value of higher education in America. Biden argues that this move is essential for making higher education a bridge to the middle class, not a barrier.

Criticism has been swift and sharp, especially from conservative quarters. South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem accuses the President of leveraging the debt forgiveness plan as a political tool to "buy votes." Such strong words reflect the deep divisions this policy has unearthed, suggesting that the debate over student loan forgiveness is as much about fiscal responsibility as it is about educational accessibility.

The heart of Biden's plan, the Savings on Valuable Education (SAVE) plan, specifically targets borrowers under certain conditions for debt cancellation. This plan, announced in February, represents a tailored approach to debt relief, aiming to balance the immediate financial relief for borrowers with the broader implications of such forgiveness on the national debt.

The Clash with the Supreme Court

In June 2023, the U.S. Supreme Court delivered a significant blow to Biden's aspirations, ruling 6-3 against a proposal valued at $430 billion in student loan forgiveness. This decision did not deter Biden but solidified his resolve to pursue alternative paths to achieve his goals. "From day one, I promised to fix broken student loan programs and ensure higher education is a ticket to the middle class, not a barrier to opportunity. I’m not backing down," Biden wrote on X, showcasing his unwavering commitment to this cause.

Governor Noem's remarks echo a broader conservative critique of Biden's plan. She argues that the plan exacerbates the nation's fiscal woes and strategically distracts from other crises, such as border security and the rising cost of living. Noem's pointed critique paints the forgiveness plan as financially imprudent and a deliberate political maneuver to secure reelection.

Noem argued:

He's buying votes. That's exactly what he's doing. The timing of this, to follow through on what he has threatened to do for so long, is incredibly hypocritical of him to say that he cares about this country and continue to accumulate debt and hand out money to get himself re-elected.

Navigating Political and Fiscal Turbulence

The political ramifications of Biden's plan extend beyond the fiscal implications. They delve into the heart of America's political divide, pitting visions of educational accessibility against stern warnings of fiscal irresponsibility. Biden's plan, particularly the SAVE plan, is an attempt to navigate these choppy waters, offering a lifeline to borrowers while attempting to counteract the critiques.

Yet, the Supreme Court's ruling against the initial proposal has not ended the debate; it has merely shifted the battleground. Biden's insistence on pushing forward despite this setback underscores a broader political strategy that seeks to reframe the narrative around student debt, higher education, and fiscal responsibility.


President Biden's steadfast commitment to student loan forgiveness, despite the soaring national debt and opposition from the U.S. Supreme Court, is a testament to his broader educational and fiscal agenda. The initiative has sparked significant debate, with critics like South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem accusing the President of using the plan to "buy votes."

Despite these challenges, Biden's SAVE plan aims to provide targeted debt relief to borrowers, illustrating the administration's attempt to balance financial relief with fiscal concerns. The Supreme Court's ruling against Biden's initial proposal has not deterred him; instead, it has reaffirmed his resolve to seek alternative paths for relief. As the nation watches, this policy move could redefine the landscape of higher education financing and the political implications of fiscal policy in America.

About Aileen Barro

With years of experience at the forefront of political commentary, Robert Cunningham brings a blend of sharp wit and deep insight to his analysis of American principles at the Capitalism Institute.

Top Articles



Receive information on new articles posted, important topics and tips.
Join Now
We won't send you spam. 
Unsubscribe at any time.

Recent Articles

Recent Analysis

Copyright © 2024 -
A Project of Connell Media.