Biden's Israel Policy Criticized by Top House Armed Services Democrat

 May 11, 2024

A recent statement by President Joe Biden suggesting the potential withholding of weapons from Israel has sparked criticism from within his party.

Rep. Adam Smith argues that the public nature of Biden's threat might inadvertently ease pressure on Hamas, hindering progress toward a ceasefire, Breitbart News reported.

Understanding the Context of Biden's Statements

During an appearance on CNN's "News Central," Rep. Adam Smith, a prominent Democrat on the House Armed Services Committee, voiced his concerns about the president's strategy.

The issue centers on President Biden's public declaration regarding the withholding of specific military support from Israel if it proceeded to penetrate densely populated areas in Rafah, Gaza.

This proclamation came against ongoing tensions and violence in the region. Rep. Smith indicated that such discussions usually happen behind closed doors and that making them public could be seen as a shift in the U.S.'s stance towards Israel, potentially affecting international and domestic perceptions.

The Impact on Israeli-American Relations

Smith pointed out that these kinds of end-use restrictions on weapons were not unprecedented and mentioned their use in other contexts, such as Ukraine. "Here [are] your weapons, can’t fire into Russia," he noted, illustrating the selective application of military aid based on operational limitations to mitigate conflict escalation.

Moreover, Rep. Smith underscored the complexities of the geopolitical situation, suggesting that the ceasefire deal proposed by President Biden had been stalled primarily due to Hamas' demands. These include a complete and permanent withdrawal of Israeli forces and a phased return of hostages—terms that have not been acceptable to Israel.

Hamas and the Ceasefire Stalemate

Rep. Adam Smith frankly discussed the main hurdles in achieving a ceasefire, pointing out that the primary resistance came from Hamas, a perspective he believes has not been adequately covered in the media. He elaborated on the ceasefire dynamics in his conversation on CNN.

Rep. Adam Smith shared, "Because, look, the biggest block to a ceasefire right now is Hamas. And that’s being largely underreported. There has been a ceasefire agreement on the table for months, which the President brokered, to allow for the return of hostages and a temporary ceasefire."

He also addressed criticisms directed at President Biden, attributing them to political motivations and the charged atmosphere around U.S. foreign policy debates. "It’s a small part of the larger problem… I think this has been blown out of proportion. The U.S. still supports Israel. We also want to improve the humanitarian situation in Gaza. That’s the very difficult terrain the President is trying to navigate," he noted.

Balancing Support and Humanitarian Concerns

The dilemmas facing U.S. policymakers are steep. On one side, maintaining robust support for Israel, an essential ally, and on the other, addressing the humanitarian crises that unfold recurrently in Gaza due to the enduring conflict.

Rep. Smith used his platform to clarify that the discussion about restricting military aid was not indicative of a broader U.S. withdrawal of support for Israel but rather a strategic maneuver within a specific military and tactical context. This approach, according to Smith, should ideally push Hamas towards more conciliatory stances in ceasefire negotiations.

As tensions continue to simmer, the international community watches closely, mindful of the delicate balance President Biden and his administration must strike. They aim for peace and stability in a region long fraught with conflict while maintaining strategic partnerships and navigating domestic political pressures.

About Victor Winston

Victor is a freelance writer and researcher who focuses on national politics, geopolitics, and economics.

Top Articles



Receive information on new articles posted, important topics and tips.
Join Now
We won't send you spam. 
Unsubscribe at any time.

Recent Articles

Recent Analysis

Copyright © 2024 -
A Project of Connell Media.